Self (archive footage)

Self

Self

Self

Self

Gabriel

Self

Self (archive footage)

Ivan Lucre

Oscar Diggs (voice)

Tiger (voice)

Lenny

Chef

Father O'Rdeal

Jeremy (voice)

Itchy Itchiford (voice)

The Oddfather

Tiger (voice)

Self - Roastee (archive footage)

Il giudice

Dom

Itchy Itchiford (voice)

Jerry

Mr. Fallon

Father Drobney

Stanley (voice)

Self - Host

Dr. Animal Cannibal Pizza

Don Giovanni

Self

Rip (voice)

Sound Man

Dr. Beckhard

Munchie (voice)

Christopher Columbus (voice)

Self - Host / Narrator (voice)

Nicodemus (voice)

Tiger (voice)

Mr. B

Harry 'The Hippo' Gutterman

Itchy Itchiford (voice)

The Looking Glass (voice)

Fagin (voice)

Capitano T. Favretto

Big Bad Joe Hopkins

Pizza the Hutt (voice)

Tiger (voice)

Aunt Kate Abbot

Self

The Pope

Victor Prinzim / Captain Chaos / Don Canneloni

Roger Hanover

Melvin P. Thorpe

Jeremy (voice)

Self

The Producer

Self

Victor

Emperor Nero

Doc

Shadrach

Himself

Walter Holmes

Dominick DiNapoli

Ernie Fortunato

Bernie the Agent

Self

Himself

Pepe Damascus

Marlon Borunki

Dan Turner

Adolph Zitz

Self

Dom Bell

Eduardo Gambetti

Murray West

Buddy Bizarre

Mario Azzecca

Logan Delp

Irwin Marcy

Bill Bird

Father Fyodor

Self

J. Gardner Monroe

Kurt Brock

Julius Pritter

TSgt. Collins

Marvin Rollins

Thomas Moon (uncredited)