Ned Buntline (flashback sequence) (archive footage)

Simon Baines

The Mayor

Holborn Gaines

Skimmerhorn

Judge Wallis

Alfred Gaylord

PInky

Anton Gravesend

Doctor Brewer

Mr. Taylor

Miller

Doc Lovejoy

Tobias aka Toby

Judge Wilcox

Edgar Alden Franklin Smith

Mr. Delacourt

Thaddeus 'Thad' Kring

Ragueneau

Sharpie Corrigan

Judge Millett

Major Adams

John Barker

Parnell

J.B. Hutchins

Mr. Evergood

Uncle Zeke Tinker

Emmanuel Catt

Matt Brady

Attorney Dutton

'Pop' Sam Scully

Hugo Denton

McKinley

'Pops'

D'Albernasi

The Late Timothy Beecher

Rev. Polly

Ben Otis

Geoffrey Holden

Emmerrich Johnson

Little Joe

Fred J. Johnson

Dwight Chandwick

Detective Latham

Sheriff of Nottingham

Arthur Manleder

King Louis XVI

Beaster

John Massey

Dr. Bruce Clayworth

Jaroslaw "Papa" Haschek

Marty Maizely

Professor Hanley

Mr. Connors

Mr. Mahoney - Grocer

Police Chief Davis

Ulysses Sylvester Rogers

Clem Prouty

Prof. Frederick Walthers

Sheik Abdul El Khim

Arthur Manleder

Charles Grant Sr.

Lloyd Corrigan

John Whipple

Anatol Duprez

Kraley

Arthur Manleder

Inspector Harris

Franz Erhart

Maurice Vaughn

Mr. Secretary

Ernest Higgins

Arthur Manleder

J.C. Thomas

Mr. Marshall J. Denningham

Thomas Woverman

Gobelin

Arthur Manleder

Gray Kingsford

Doctor Curtis

George Lewis

Montague Foster

Arthur Manleder

Chumley

Mr. Cadwallader

Harvey Upshaw

Roger Gorton

Pigeon Duncan

Baron Stephens

Hugh Stackett

Randolph Stone

Capt. Stannage

Prosecuting Attorney

Otis Winfield

C. Jason - Photographer

Martin

Anton Zarecki (uncredited)

Judge

Dr. Pender

Mr. Higby (uncredited)

Dr. Henry Wallace, Principal

Jemuel

Yacht Cabin Boy (uncredited)