Doctor Esposito

Anthony's Dad (voice)

Crystal Bobby

Coach Krieger

Jeremy Murdoch

Tommy

Benny

Renda

Detective Martinez

Keith

Reverend John

Newton

Father Quinn

The Governor

Walker

Detective Kane

Charlie

Boston Brand / Deadman (voice)

Mike Silvia

Remy

Nick Manero

Referee

Travis Verdon

Moretti

Antonio

Manny

Franco Dalia

Gianni DiCarlo

Grant

Jimmy Calone

Ceasar Novak

Phil Winters

Officer D'Agostino

Renaldo Pinera

Officer Colin Pierce

Travis Erickson

Officer Colovito

Vincent

Brucie

Angelo Buono

Sheriff Duncan

Johnny Ramos

Harry

Anthony

Joe Jr.

Chet Forte

Eddie Colucci

Cop #1 (voice)

Det. Tony Nenonen

Major Ray Domino

Sammy 'The Bull' Gravano

Stick

Grasso

Al Williams

Mike

Ring Announcer / Interviewer

Ralph

Junior

Father Carlos (segment 'The First Commandment')

Big Al Brown

Boston Cop

Tony Gloves

Danny D'Arcangelo

Vinny

Bingo

Josh Flatbush

Policeman (uncredited)