Santa Claus

Old Al Casey

Dr. Kasper

Buckmaster

Monsignor Ryan

Omar Khayam

Mr. Pemberton

Bernard Ranley

Harry Willis

Bishop

Monsignor Monaghan

Dean Joshua Updike

Captain Joe

Cardinal Hugolino

Doc Bayles

Professor Plumcutt

Dr. A.A. Andrews

Dr. Enos Davis

Tom McKay

James Fusenot

Osbert Sorenson

Governor

Bill Lawrence

Patrick J. Sullivan

Thadeus Jackson

Prof. Elson

Mr. Parry

Dr. Willoughby

Dr. Reverend Thomas Chamberlain

Pop Smith

Lord Herbert

Tim McCarey

Colonel Travers

Jonathan Huntoon Smith

Hurree Chunder

Dr. Chumley

Nathaniel B. Wakely VI

Kevin Maguire

Slush Tubbs

Matthews

Judge Alexander Adamson

Jean le Maistre, Inquisitor of Rouen

Horace (A Leprechaun)

Jonathan Turner

Jeremy Love

Cecil Kellaway

Tom Carter

Count D'Armand

J.B. Allenbury

Nick Smith

Mac

Thomas Gainsborough

Marvin P. Meglin

Doctor Weeks

Edward VII, Prince of Wales

William

Jim Hilton

King O'Hara

Pop Tibbets

Dinner Guest

Alfred Fortescue

Daniel

Solvani (archive footage / uncredited)

Dan Odell

Uncle George

Cecil Kellaway (uncredited)

Peter Miles

Captain Jack Risingwell

Oscar, the Drunk

Granet

Henry Randall

Shipboard Host

O'Leary

Angus McBragel

Professor Starkweather

Dr. Spencer

Mr. Chapman

Prescott

Henry Putnam

Mr. Chumley

Noah

The Great Solvani

Brother Goodwin

Franklin Morris

Philip Barton

Emerson

Inspector Sampson

Mr. Chumley

Judge

Charles Moler

Mr. Wendelhares

Headwaiter (uncredited)

Colonial Official

Earnshaw

George Chedworth

Mr. Stebbins (uncredited)

Reginald Roland

Barrett

Rufus Trent

Phillips - Gene's Butler

Police Chief Hardy

Geoffrey

Willard Lorryweather

Fentriss, aka Gilhooley

Mr. Beyers

Fletcher's Butler (unconfirmed)

Hubert Blaydon

Dad Hayseed